What is the constitutional order of the European Union now?

It is a commonly asked question – what is the legal basis (the constitutional framework) under which the European Union is operating now? This is debated by academics and legal practitioners. But most of the European officials and politicians seem to have closed their eyes – they act as if there was no problem and the EU constitutional order is developing in a way it was developing for the last couple of decades. The current structure of the constitutional framework for the EU is clear – the basis is all the treaties, the last one being the Treaty of Nice. From this perspective, the treaties are as valid as they were a two or five years ago. However, there is one problem with this analysis. And this problem is the negative referenda in the Netherlands and France concerning the adoption of the Constitution of Europe. The analysis should start by looking at what exactly the Constitution of Europe was trying to do. The Constitution contained very few reforms and areas which were new to the European constitutional order. The main aim was to codify the previous treaties and to simplify the whole system. Using this analysis things start to look rather different. If the Constitution of Europe was codification of the previous treaties, is it not true to say that a ‘no’ vote in the two referenda was an implied ‘no’ to the treaties themselves? Obviously it is much easier for the EU officials to just use the current framework as if the referenda on the Constitution were a completely separated issue which had nothing to do with the treaties themselves. But is it really so? Does not the legal analysis of the situation lead to a conclusion that the people of Europe have rejected the treaties as well? Or should we also take into consideration the non-legal argument that the European Union has no real alternative as going back to the original treaties?

Bitte beachten Sie: Dieser Artikel ist nicht mehr im Original verfügbar.

  • Infos zum Artikel
  • Kommentare
  • Ähnliches

Themen: European Union

Erschienen 5. Dezember 2005 auf http://mehrsprachigkeit.blogspot.com.

Sie haben eine Meinung zum Thema? Artikels kommentieren
Artikel kommentieren

The Australian Treaties Database

Handakte WebLAWg | 4. Dezember 2007 — The Australian Treaties Database (ATD) is an on-line resource for researching treaties to which Australia is a signatory, or wh…

France Will Never Let Turkey In. EU Constitution Is Dead

Law & Justice | 8. März 2006 — In an interview with EurActiv Romania, Professor of European Politics Anand Menon of Birmingham University talks about EU enlargem…

European Union Law /Links bei LLRX.com

Transblawg | 4. Oktober 2006 — LLRX.com is only updated once a month nowadays, but it’s always worth looking at the old stuff - a lot of foreign legal syste…

New Forum: "Debate Europe"

Law & Justice | 28. März 2006 — The EU has opened a new website 'Debate Europe'. It is part of the EU's "Plan D" – where D stands for Dialogue, Debate and Democ…

Austria and Denmark Fear American-Style European Court of Justice

Law & Justice | 13. Januar 2006 — The Austrian presidency of the EU received backing by Denmark on another issue related to the future of Europe: Austria's critic…

EU reform treaty / EU-Reform-Vertrag

Transblawg | 17. Juli 2007 — EUobserver reports that last Thursday, Giuliano Amato said “They [EU leaders] decided that the document should be unreadable.…

Legal Education and ICT-Law in Europe

Law & Justice | 23. April 2006 — An increasing number of Law Faculties in Europe have established research institutes or introduced teaching courses. See for examp…

Gateway “Trial Lawyers Europe” now officially online

Rechthaber | 11. Dezember 2008 — The new website www.trial-lawyers-europe.com provides information on European law and the law of European countries. It is a ga…

European Constitution Is Not Dead

Law & Justice | 7. März 2006 — Last Saturday it was revealed that German Chancellor Angela Merkel and French president Jacques Chirac, have devised a Franco-Germ…

How to sue in Europe

Rechthaber | 6. März 2009 — For a foreign client, taking legal action in Europe is a complex issue. Each European country has its own national laws, court …