Trademark protection of File Extensions in Europe

US CAD company Autodesk's efforts to monopolise the ".dwg" file extension via a pending US “DWG” word mark application (No. 78 852 798) claiming all kinds of "computer software", have, even though the USPTO has not yet issued a final refusal to register the mark, meanwhile led to the satisfactory result that file extentions cannot be trademark protected in the US (see, e.g., here, here, or my earlier post). Even though Autodesk had to disavow the US lawsuit Autodesk vs DS SolidWorks that, as fas as Autodesk is concerned, anyone in the world is free to use “.dwg” as a file extension (cf. doc 241, filed on December 31, 2009; see also here), a file extension is in fact to be considered descriptive and/or generic due to its functional use, while it is a fundamental rule of US trademark law that trademark protection is not issued on symbols or marks that are entirely functional. In Europe, Autodesk applied for a Community Trademark "DWG" (No. 004703641) claiming, inter alia, "Computer software; computer aided design software; software developer tools; software for sharing information in a secure environment; downloadable software", which meanwhile has been withdrawn after two oppositions filed by opponents "Knowledge Base Software (Pty) Ltd" and "DS SolidWorks Corporation" and a subsequent appeal. In Germany, two parallel “DWG” word marks are currently pending - No. 3020090602751 and No. 3020090276943 - the latter being a conversion of the withdrawn CTM registration -, both claiming computer software, CAD software or the like, which may, if granted, potentially be used to prohibit usage of the “.dwg” file extension in Germany. However, even though Autodesk's respective disavowal in the US lawsuit is irelevant in Germany, Autodesk's German trademarks most likely cannot be used to obstruct using “.dwg” file extensions, since appropriate legal measures and arguments exist to both attack a potentially granted mark and, if necessary, defend against an infringement threat. File extensions are technical indications of a file's format and, as such, cannot be registered due to absolute grounds for refusal according to § 8 II MarkenG (German Trademark Act), since, in my opinion, such signs are devoid of any distinctive character (§ 8 II, 1) and/or consist exclusively of indications which may serve to designate the kind, intended purpose or other characteristics of the claimed goods or services (§ 8 II, 2), in analogy to the related US doctrine. Autodesk may still argue that, according to § 8 III MarkenG, “DWG” has established itself in affected trade circles as distinguishing sign such that possible absolute grounds for refusal have been overcome. In fact, Autodesk has already argued along this line in the above-mentioned US lawsuit Autodesk vs DS SolidWorks (cf. doc 1, Complaint, filed on September 19, 2008; see also here) by asserting that design professionals would recognize “DWG” as the name of Autodesk's proprietary technology and file format (doc 1, §§ 9…

» Vollständiger Artikel
  • Infos zum Artikel
  • Kommentare
  • Ähnliches
  • Links

Themen: Word Mark , Community Trademark , Uspto , Autodesk , Dwg , File Extension , US Trademark Law , Trademarks , Absolute Grounds

Erschienen 11. Juni 2010 auf http://www.visaepatentes.com.

Sie haben eine Meinung zum Thema? Artikels kommentieren
Artikel kommentieren

File Extensions cannot be Trademark Protected in the US

Visae Patentes | 6. Juni 2010 — Well-known US CAD company Autodesk Inc. holds, inter alia, pending “DWG” word mark application (No. 78 852 798) claiming “compute…

TM (R) (C) Pat. Pend.

Law & Justice | 10. Oktober 2005 — What do those symbols mean? TM TM stands for trademark. A trademark is a word, phrase, symbol or design, or a combination of t…

Ferrero vs. UEFA, part II

servicemarks | 5. September 2007 — Lately, there has been an interesting inflation of EM 2008 marks registered in Germany. It offers an insight into a highly interes…

US-Marken- und Urheberrecht

USA Recht | 15. Oktober 2011 — Nachfolgend ein kleiner Überblick zum US-Gewerblichen Rechtsschutz, Auszug aus der September / Oktober 2011 Ausgabe German Ame…

US Copyright First Sale Doctrine Not Applicable to Licenses for Digital Medial Products

Visae Patentes | 22. September 2010 — As reported on the Internet Cases blog and the Austin Technology Law blog, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal recently decided the…

O2 gives Deutsche Telekom Magenta Blues

servicemarks | 4. September 2007 — Yet another colour CTM cancellation action On the face of it, Red Bull and Deutsche Telekom have only little in common. While …

Foreign Trademark Domestically Protected

German American Law Journal :: American Edition | 26. Juli 2009 — CK - Washington.   Despite the fact that an unregistered trademark is used in Germany, a conflicting mark may be registered with t…

US Copyright First Sale Doctrine Not Applicable to Licenses for Digital Medial Products

Visae Patentes | 22. September 2010 — As reported on the Internet Cases blog and the Austin Technology Law blog, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal recently decided the…

Klage wg. DMCA-Missbrauch

Handakte WebLAWg | 14. September 2007 — Der Software-Hersteller Autodesk wird in einem zivilen Rechtsstreit in den USA - verkürzt gesagt - des Betrugs bezichtigt. Au…

Beware the German Domain Rule

German American Law Journal :: American Edition | 18. Juli 2008 — CK - Washington.   In the dim ages of the Internet, trademark law and domain law were two separate branches of the law. Trademark …

Latest Status Info
Autodesk - Developer Center - Autodesk Developer Network
Autodesk - Developer Center - RealDWG
Sorry...
DPMA - Startseite

DPMA - Deutsches Patent- und Markenamt, die Zentralbehörde auf dem Gebiet des gewerblichen Rechtsschutzes in Deutschland


File extensions cannot be trademarks | Internet Cases - Evan Brown, Chicago attorney internet and intellectual property
Court Says File Extensions Not Eligible For Trademarks... Sorta | Techdirt
"Knowledge Base Software (Pty) Ltd" - Google-Suche
Registerauskunft des Deutschen Patent- und Markenamtes (DPMA)
Registerauskunft des Deutschen Patent- und Markenamtes (DPMA)
Germany: Marks (No. 89/104/EEC), Reform Law (Consolidation), 25/10/1994 (16/07/1998)
DOC (computing) - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Portable Document Format - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Microsoft - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Adobe Systems - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
dwg software - Google-Suche
Germany: Marks (No. 89/104/EEC), Reform Law (Consolidation), 25/10/1994 (16/07/1998)
Blogger: Sign in
Germany: Marks (No. 89/104/EEC), Reform Law (Consolidation), 25/10/1994 (16/07/1998)
Germany: Marks (No. 89/104/EEC), Reform Law (Consolidation), 25/10/1994 (16/07/1998)