Investment in new technologies in markets of electronic communications – can it live together with regulation? (Part 2)

But this does not seem to be the end of the story yet. Last Friday a Deutsche Telekom spokesman said that DT was still not satisfied with the situation, i.e., the fact that the VDSL market will be regulated. In addition, the French Industry Minister Francois Loos has said lately that the government is examining an industrial policy that will favour investments by France Telecom and other telecom network operators for high-speed internet. In an interview published on Monday in La Tribune he stated that he would not want the service providers to decide not to invest in new technologies in markets of electronic communications out of the fear that their networks would be opened up to competitors which do not have the same cost-risk. It is significant to point out that this statement comes after France Telekom cut its 2005 revenue guidance (again!). Well it is clear that France is rather restricted as to how exactly this new industrial policy could look like – as long as there is the current European regulatory framework which foresees regulation in the discussed markets, France will remain limited as to whether the regulation of those markets could be relaxed. Therefore, this statement clearly means that France will do everything possible to influence the review process of the regulatory framework in order to achieve that the new regulatory framework will allow denying competitors access to networks in those markets. The European Commission still seems to remain in favour of the main ideas behind the current regulatory framework. The main arguments are the huge price decreases and more choice to consumers as a result of increased competition over the last few years. Furthermore, it is also pointed out that the calls for allowing regulatory holidays do not come from for example the Nordic countries which are most successful for opening up markets to competition, decreasing prices and ensuring levels of penetration, which are amongst the highest in the world. It is pointed out that the countries which seem to be very keen on not allowing competition in markets which require high levels of investments, for example Germany, are doing not so well in terms of those criteria when compared with the rest of Europe. In addittion, another strong argument used by the Commission is that the competitors of Deutsche Telekom, for example, United Internet, have offered to co-finance the required investment in the VDSL markets. Therefore, the argument used by Deutsche Telekom that if access to their networks is allowed in those markets the competitors would be free-riding on the DT investment simply fails: if the competitors take part in co-financing the investment the cost of innovation is split up equally amongst all the involved firms. However, one also cannot forget the US model which foresees much less regulation of markets of electronic communications, especially those requiring high levels of investment. Nobody has ever claimed that the EU model is any better than the US model. Maybe the US model offers ‘the ultimate solution’ to this debate? Furthermore, the European Commission will not be able to ignore the two most influential Member States of the European Union in their calls to allow regulatory holidays for certain markets which require high levels of innovation costs during the review process of the regulatory framework. This is even more so if they manage to persuade the public that more regulation can lead to less investment…

Bitte beachten Sie: Dieser Artikel ist nicht mehr im Original verfügbar.

  • Infos zum Artikel
  • Kommentare
  • Ähnliches

Themen: Deutsche Telekom , France Telecom

Erschienen 17. Januar 2006 auf http://mehrsprachigkeit.blogspot.com.

Sie haben eine Meinung zum Thema? Artikels kommentieren
Artikel kommentieren

Investment in new technologies in markets of electronic communications – can it live together with regulation? (part 1)

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 17. Januar 2006 — This will be a very significant year for the development of markets of electronic communications – the review process of the exist…

New Trends in Telecommunications 3 – Implications for Lawyers

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 5. Dezember 2005 — One might ask if the previous observations concerning the newest developments in the area of electronic communications really have…

Follow up – developments in the Deutsche Telekom plans concerning the new high-speed VDSL markets

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 21. Dezember 2005 — Several months ago it was described on this website that the new German coalition government had undertaken not to regulate the ne…

General principles on regulating telecommunication markets in the EU (commenting on concerns regarding Deutsche Telekom)

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 21. November 2005 — The basic feature of the EU regulatory framework for electronic communications is that markets must be regulated. It is obvious …

EU worried about the German coalition plans in relation to telecommunications

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 21. November 2005 — The new German government will no doubt bring some change to how the German economy has been working so far. Some of the proposed …

New Trends in Telecommunications 2 – Convergence

Die neue Mehrsprachigkeit | 5. Dezember 2005 — The most important implication of the technological innovations in the area of electronic communications (especially of the descri…

A review of solar energy: markets, economics and policies

LEXEGESE | 8. Januar 2012 — by Govinda R. Timilsina, Lado Kurdgelashvili, Patrick A. Narbel Solar energy has experienced phenomenal growth in recent years…

Swiss Stock Exchange Act: The Swiss Banking Business

German American Law Journal :: American Edition | 18. März 2005 — SKe - Washington.  The new edition of Das Schweizerische Bankgeschäft, The Swiss Banking Business, by Urs Emch, Hugo Renz, Reto Ar…

EU Commission is taking steps to reinforce the robustness of the CO2 market

LEXEGESE | 20. Oktober 2011 — The European Commission adopted on 20 October 2011 a proposal for the review of financial market rules, bringing into their scope …

Ambitions of the Energy Infrastructure Package

LEXEGESE | 30. Januar 2012 — ● by Günther Oettinger, EU Commissioner for Energy ● Speech held in Brussels at the Council of European Energy Regulators (CEE…